VCE IT Lecture Notes by Mark Kelly, McKinnon Secondary College
Last changed: February 18, 2011 9:18 AM

The difference between EFFICIENCY and EFFECTIVENESS


EFFICIENCY
means: saving TIME, MONEY or EFFORT

EFFECTIVENESS means how well the the job gets done; how well a system achieves its intended goals. e.g. accuracy, reliability, fun, ease of use, beauty.

EFFICIENCY and EFFECTIVENESS do not mean the same thing! In fact, they are often natural enemies. Often you can have one, or the other, but not both (unless you are lucky or you want to spend a lot of money.)

Being efficient means you spend less time on something, you spend less money on something or you spend less effort (or number of workers) on something. You will not often get all three types of efficiency. Which one you aim for depends on what you are trying to achieve.

Being effective means you do your job well. In other words, the output (finished product) is of high quality.

It is a rare and delightful occasion where a solution to a problem is both efficient and effective; you usually have to decide which you prefer, because you usually cannot have both.

In some organisations, efficiency is important and quality is secondary. The Novelty Christmas Hat Co. Pty Ltd may be such a case. The public would not be rioting in the streets if there was 6% less glitter on next year's Christmas hats, but the company would want to produce the hats efficiently (with little wasted time, money or effort.)

In other organisations, effectiveness is important and efficiency is secondary. If you were in charge of building a system to defend your country against incoming intercontinental thermonuclear missles, would you be willing to fail to detect a few missiles and lose a few cities to save a few million dollars? Not likely. You would be willing to spend all that was required to attain maximum effectiveness.

One can only be grateful that the manager of Novelty Christmas Hat Co. Pty Ltd is not in charge of national security.

On the other hand, if the head of national nuclear defence were making party hats and didn't change his views, he would probably produce silly party hats that could withstand gales, lightning, gas attacks and flamethrowers at a cost of $24,938 each.

You can see that each organisation needs to balance efficiency against effectiveness and where there is a conflict between efficiency and quality, the organisation must decide what is more important to them. The decision will often be determined by their organisational goals. Some organisations are more willing to sacrifice quality for efficiency; some do the opposite. Organisations like 'The $2 Shop' obviously value efficiency over effectiveness. Customers save money. Rolls-Royce value effectiveness over efficiency: to them, quality is everything, and they sacrifice efficiency to achieve it.

EFFICIENCY.

Repeat after me: EFFICIENCY means: saving TIME, MONEY or EFFORT

If the Novelty Christmas Hat Co. Pty Ltd wanted to be more efficient, it could reduce the quality of the merry quips in their Christmas bonbons by employing illiterate Eskimo joke writers with no sense of humour.

In their case, efficiency is a key organsisational goal, while effectiveness is not. They would not suffer too much if 20% fewer party-goers found their bonbon jokes tedious, lame and full of references to polar bears.

 

EFFECTIVENESS.

Repeat after me: EFFECTIVENESS means how well the the job gets done. e.g. accuracy, reliability, fun, ease of use, beauty.

In some circumstances, the quality of the finished product counts for everything, and no scrimping and saving could justify a reduction in quality. Such products are usually expensive, but customers are willing to buy them for their quality.

 

In the real world, there is always a decision to be made about how far you should go to achieve either efficiency or effectiveness. A balance needs to be struck. The examples of the Novelty Hat Co. and the Missile Defence Organisation are extremes: most organisations are inbetween, and must constantly make judgements about what is more important for a particular system: effectiveness or efficiency - or some degree of both?

 

Back to the IT Lecture Notes index

© Mark Kelly 2001

VCE IT Lecture notes (c) Mark Kelly, McKinnon Secondary College